Epistemic status: talking with Claude, and some guy’s thread on Twitter.1
The sun gives you cancer, but also nitric oxide and vitamin D2. The benefits of these two probably outweigh the all-cause mortality risks of cancer3, so it’s worth getting regular sun exposure4. But in the winter, in most places including where I live, there’s not enough sun.
My claim: we should be able to fix this with Technology, approximately today. Probably with small tweaks on existing tanning beds. Someone please make this business so I can pay you money.
more background
(Remember my epistemic status here)
The sun produces UVA and UVB light. UVA hitting your skin produces nitric oxide, which lowers your blood pressure. But too much UVA causes skin cancer (melanoma, the bad kind) and skin aging. UVB produces vitamin D, but too much causes sunburn and skin cancer (carcinoma and melanoma). UVA is what I care about here, because vitamin D also comes in a pill.5
UVA is what’s in many tanning beds. People thought it was safe because it doesn’t burn you much without the UVB, but it turns out it still causes cancer and skin aging. So, still don’t go to a tanning salon.
but why not a better tanning bed?
If some amount of UVA is good, it can’t be the case that tanning beds are unilaterally bad! Claude’s explanation is:
- you can’t tell how much UVA you’re getting
- the beds are set to produce a tan fast, so you’re probably getting way too much
- who knows they might be cheap and give you UVB too
To which I say, skill issue. Make a bed that gives you 20 J/cm^2 of UVA at whatever speed is safe! Include a UV sensor that shuts off when you’re done! Hell, include a SAD lamp with more lux while you’re at it. Franchise in every city in Europe and the top half of the US. I would like to be less sad and have lower blood pressure in the winter.
yeah I feel a little weird about this. But I still feel comfortable posting it. I guess it’s because it’s some combination of “just an idea” and can’t be that far off. I guess I should lose a couple credibility points if this is too far wrong. ↩︎
so, it;s impossible to say if its bad or not, ↩︎
and here’s where I quote Some Guy On Twitter. Here’s the thread again. But ok he’s a dermatologist at least and abstract-scanning his papers checks out, idk ↩︎
plus, and more to my interests, it may make you less depressed? theoretically that’s visible light but I don’t know, sun good ↩︎
maybe you, like me, remember vaguely “vitamin D pills don’t work”. I think this intuition came from studies where vitamin D pills don’t improve all cause mortality, but sun exposure does. This is because of (among other things) the nitric oxide from UVA! But vitamin D is still worth getting: it helps your body absorb calcium and build bones, and maybe has some anti-autoimmunity effect. ↩︎
blog 2026 2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012